Ranked by shop reviews
Highest rated eye makeup
The eye makeup with the best star ratings from shop reviews on YesStyle and StyleKorean, with a quote from a real buyer for each.
- 1
Clio · StyleKorean
Clio *new* Kill Lash Super Proof Mascara (3 Types)
★★★★★ 5.0 (143 reviews on StyleKorean)
R281 US$17.00 in StyleKorean's Awin feed, 10 Jul 2026
View at StyleKorean - 2
Clio · StyleKorean
Clio *Koshort Edition* Pro Eye Palette (2 colors)
★★★★★ 4.9 (19 reviews on StyleKorean)
R512 US$31.00 in StyleKorean's Awin feed, 10 Jul 2026
View at StyleKorean - 3
Ando · StyleKorean
Ando SHIKOOTAENG Brown Edition (30 Sticks)
★★★★★ 4.6 (63 reviews on StyleKorean)
R476 US$28.80 in StyleKorean's Awin feed, 10 Jul 2026
View at StyleKorean - 4
Clio · StyleKorean
Clio *Every Fruit Grocery* Pro Eye Palette Air (2 Colors)
★★★★★ 5.0 (4 reviews on StyleKorean)
R533 US$32.30 in StyleKorean's Awin feed, 10 Jul 2026
View at StyleKorean - 5
Blessed · StyleKorean
Blessed Moon Black hole Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner (3 Colors)
★★★★★ 4.2 (10 reviews on StyleKorean)
R189 US$11.44 in StyleKorean's Awin feed, 10 Jul 2026
View at StyleKorean - 6
Blessed · StyleKorean
Blessed Moon Blackhole Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner (3 Colors)
★★★★★ 4.2 (10 reviews on StyleKorean)
R189 US$11.44 in StyleKorean's Awin feed, 10 Jul 2026
View at StyleKorean
How this list works: we read the star rating and review count from each shop's own product page on 12 October 2026. Products with fewer than three reviews are left out. To stop a single five-star review beating hundreds of 4.7s, we rank with a weighted average that pulls small review counts towards 4.3. Review quotes are copied from the shop page and credited to the reviewer. Stylevana and Jolse product pages didn't return ratings to us, so their products can't appear here yet.